Your wine glass and whether you hold it determines how much you pour
Walker, Doug, Laura Smarandescu, and Brian Wansink (2014). Half full or empty: Cues that lead wine drinkers to unintentionally overpour. Substance Use & Misuse, 49(3), 295-302. doi:10.3109/10826084.2013.832327
After a long week, you relax and pour yourself a glass of wine—but could the wine glass you choose cause you to pour more than you think? After witnessing how environmental cues like plate size and food labels impact eating behaviors, researchers decided to take a look at how similar factors impact drinking experiences. In their new study by Doug Walker, Laura Smarandescu, and Brian Wansink, drinkers unintentionally poured larger servings when their glasses were wider, when the pourers held them in their hands, and when the glassware matched the wine.
For this study, the researchers recruited 73 students (all of legal drinking age) who drank at least one glass of wine a week. The students were brought to several different stations and were asked to pour themselves a normal serving of wine. At each of these stations, the researchers manipulated environmental cues to measure their effects.
They used three different types of wine glasses to test the effect of size and shape: Large, Wide, or Standard. To see if participants subconsciously drank more when they anticipated a meal, some stations featured a large or small place setting. To examine the effects of pouring position, students either poured their wine into a glass they were holding or into glass placed on a table. To examine the visual effects of color contrast, there was either low contrast between the wine and the glass (white wine in a clear glass) or high contrast (red wine in a clear glass).
As the researchers suspected, several environmental cues lead to over pouring. When glasses were wider, participants poured 11.9% wine. The students poured 12.2% more wine when they were holding their glasses, compared to pouring into glasses placed on a table. When there was low contrast between the glass and the wine (white wine in a clear glass), participants poured 9.2% more wine than when there was high contrast (red wine in a clear glass).
Now you know that you’re likely to overpour if you choose a wide glass, hold your glass while serving, or select a wine that matches your glass—but the good news is that, retrospectively, people seem to be aware of how these cues influence their pours.
Click on the infographic to find out more!After each student finished the study, researchers asked them to rate the degree to which they felt each element impacted them. Overall, the students were highly accurate; they rated glass width, color contrast, and glass-holding as most influential, and those three factors had indeed lead to the most significant overpouring.
Being aware of the wine cues that impact pouring can help drinkers monitor their intake. However, knowing that you’ll pour more into a wide glass is different than knowing just how many ounces you’ll pour. When trying to monitor your alcohol consumption accurately, realize that you may be serving yourself 12% more alcohol than you originally planned. When given the option, choose a narrower glass, place your glass on a table before pouring, and select a wine that does not match your glass to avoid unintentionally over-serving!
Article summary by: Kelsey Gatto
Shape of glass and amount of alcohol poured: comparative study of effect of practice and concentration — British Medical Journal, 2005
At the movies: How external cues and perceived taste impact consumption volume — Journal of Consumer Research, 2001
Plate size and color suggestibility: The Delboeuf Illusion's bias on serving and eating behavior — Journal of Consumer Research, 2012
Environmental factors that increase the food intake and consumption volume of unknowing consumers — Annual Review of Nutrition, 2004
Content Editor: Sandra Cuellar-Healey
and Katherine Baildon
Design, Maintenance: Nadia A. Streletskaya