What's With the Color of Your Plate?
Van Ittersum, Koert, & Wansink, B. (2012). Plate size and color suggestibility: The Delboeuf illusion's bias on serving and eating behavior. Journal of Consumer Research, 39(2), 215-228
Does the color of your plate affect how much you eat?
Koert Van Ittersum Plate Research
Does the color of your plate affect how much you eat? A new study by Dr. Brian Wansink and Dr. Koert van Ittersum indicates that it does - or more specifically that the color contrast between food and plate creates an optical illusion known as the Delboeuf illusion, after the Belgian scientist who discovered it in 1865 that induces you to take more than you realize. According to Delboeuf's findings, when one looks at concentric circles, the perceived size of the interior circle changes when the circumference of the outer circle is altered: as the outer circle becomes larger, the perception is that the inner circle becomes smaller. But, you might be wondering how can this relate to portion size and plate color?
Continuing with their previous research on this topic published in 2006 and reported in 'the Large Plate Mistake!' in this section, Wansink and van Ittersum recently conducted a series of experiments to investigate other possible effects of the illusion on food serving behavior. In these new experiments they explored the effect of the color contrast between the plate and the food, and between the dinnerware and the background (i.e. tablecloth), the combined effect of plate size and color contrast between food and plate, and the effect of attention, or mindfulness, and education on the Delboeuf illusion.
To test the color contrast effect, Wansink and van Ittersum set up a study during a college reunion in upstate New York. Sixty party attendees were split up and directed to buffets serving pasta with either tomato or Alfredo sauce. In line they were randomly handed either red or white plates. After serving themselves, their portion sizes were weighed using hidden scales. What did the researchers find this time around? The results confirmed their hypothesis: participants who had low contrast between their food and the plates they served themselves on, for example pasta with Alfredo sauce on a white plate or pasta with tomato sauce on a red plate, served themselves 22% - or 32 grams ' more pasta than participants with high contrast between their food and the plate they served themselves on (i.e. pasta with tomato sauce on a white plate or pasta with Alfredo sauce on a red plate). Imagine what a difference like that can make on our waistlines, when repeated over time! Interestingly enough Wansink and van Ittersum also found that reducing the color-contrast between the dinnerware and its background (i.e. table, tablecloth or placemat) helps reduce over-serving by as much as 10%.
In addition, Wansink and van Ittersum once again confirmed that the larger the plate, the smaller people perceive the portion being served on it; that even being aware of the Delboeuf illusion does not necessarily counter-act its affects and that while education and awareness do help people make better choices, the Delboeuf illusion still impacts participant's serving sizes. So, when setting your dinner table keep in mind the Delboeuf illusion and use these findings to your advantage!
Change your dishware to better accommodate your dining needs. If your goal is to eat less, select plates that have high contrast with what you plan to serve for dinner. Want to eat more greens? Try serving them on a green plate! If replacing dinnerware is difficult, remember that tablecloths are important, too. By selecting a cloth with a low-contrast to the dinnerware, you can minimize the effect of the Delboeuf illusion and lower the likelihood of over-serving. Finally, remember The Large Plate Mistake! If you can't change the color of your dinnerware, using smaller plates leads to choosing smaller portions.