Can Kitchen Spoons Be Dangerous Spoons?
Wansink, Brian and Koert van Ittersum (2009), "How Spoons Systematically Bias Dosing of Liquid Medicine," Annals of Internal Medicine, January 5, 152, 66-67.
Cornell study shows we pour too little or too much medicine, depending on spoon size
ITHACA, NY: A new study published in the Jan. 5 issue of the Annals of Internal Medicine illustrates the dangers of using kitchen spoons to measure liquid medicine.
Former cold and flu sufferers were asked to pour one teaspoon of nighttime flu medicine into kitchen spoons of differing sizes. Depending upon the size of the spoon, the 195 former patients poured an average of eight percent too little or 12 percent too much medicine.
"When pouring into a medium–size tablespoon, participants under–dosed. But when using a larger spoon, they poured too much medicine," said Dr. Brian Wansink, Director of the Cornell Food and Brand Lab, who led the study.
"Twelve percent more may not sound like a lot, but this goes on every four to eight hours, for up to four days," Wansink explained. "So it really adds up–to the point of ineffectiveness or even danger. "
Visual illusions and spatial relationships are familiar topics in Wansink's work in food and eating behavior. In his book Mindless Eating: Why We Eat More Than We Think, he shows how smaller plates can unknowingly decrease how much people eat, and how taller glasses can decrease the amount of alcohol poured by even expert bartenders.
"Simply put, we cannot always trust our ability to estimate amounts," said the study's co–author, Dr. Koert van Ittersum, Assistant Professor of Marketing at Georgia Tech. "In some cases it may not be important, but when it comes to the health of you or your child, it is vital to make an accurate measurement. "
Behind the scenes – photo shoot.
Wansink and van Ittersum recommend using a proper device–a measuring cap or dropper, or dosing spoon or syringe–to measure liquid medicine.
Article Summary by Tom Rushmer
Paper Abstract: (available by clicking here)
- Use a measuring cap, dosing syringe, or other type of measuring tool
- Ask your pharmacist for a proper measuring device
- Slow down and pay attention to measuring right
- Follow all instructions closely