Skip to main content
New Findings
Special Features


popcorn
Food Psychology Logo

Is it a brownie you really want? Or just a hug?

Comfort foods don't have to blow your diet — if you understand the cravings

By Brian Wansink, Ph.D.
MSNBC - July 12, 2007

Most of us think of comfort foods in terms of treats like gooey chocolate brownies covered with ice cream. Fortunately, not many comfort foods are that dietetically grim.

Many people struggle with emotional eating — when we reach for food because of the way we feel, not because we're hungry — from time to time. The key is knowing the difference between real hunger and emotional cravings, and learning how to control them.

Read too many supermarket magazines and you'd think that most people gorge on fatty, sugary comfort foods when they are depressed, bored or lonely.

In reality, if you asked people to tell you what their favorite comfort food is and why they indulge, you might be surprised.
When my research team at the Cornell Food and Brand Lab asked 1,004 Americans this question, we discovered 40 percent of the favorite comfort foods people mentioned were actually fairly healthy. Pasta, soups, meats and casseroles were some of the most popular ones. Eating these dishes helped people tap into a feeling of psychological reassurance and the positive memories linked to them.

For the people we surveyed, comfort food was associated with upbeat moods. They were more likely to seek out comfort foods when they were happy (86 percent) or when they wanted to reward themselves (74 percent) than when they were depressed (39 percent) or lonely (39 percent).

Why? These foods help maintain positive feelings or soothe us. When we're in a bad mood, dishes like macaroni and cheese give a quick bump of euphoria, similar to a hug from a loved one. Research has shown that fatty or sugary foods can trigger the release of “feel good” chemicals in the brain and cut the level of stress hormones.

Mood also determines what we crave. Happy folks in the study preferred somewhat healthier foods, such as pizza or steak. People in sad moods were much more likely to reach for sugary, fatty foods such as ice cream, cookies or a bag of potato chips because they were looking for a quick way to perk themselves up emotionally.

Every potato chip and candy bar we eat is basically mainlining fat, salt and sugar. The phrase “a minute on the lips, forever on the hips” rings on hollow ears when you are feeling down and out. What matters is jolting yourself out of the dumps.

Having your cake

However, the diet strategy of saying “I’ll never eat pizza or cake again in my life” is destined for failure. Comfort foods help make life enjoyable. The key is learning how to have your cake and eat it, too — without the extra helping of guilt.

One thing you can do is to indulge with a small amount. Another thing is to have a hot food you like. Hot foods are generally more healthy (except maybe french fries) and they can be satisfying enough to short-circuit the craving. Even pizza, if it’s made with a thin whole-wheat crust and you skip the meat and add a few veggies, can be nutritious .
The basic strategy is to not deprive yourself.


For more information contact:
Brian Wansink, PhD
Food and Brand Lab, Director
110 Warren Hall
Cornell University
Ithaca, NY 14853
Email: foodandbrandlab@cornell.edu



brownie

 cardi logo and a e m logo and Cornell University


Applied Economics and Management